Silence the noisy vehicles and dangerous driving

The fine is increased, but we need enforcement, including noise photo radar.

The best enforcement is 24/7 noise photo radar issuing tickets without burdening Police officers. Provincial Government blessing is required to enable that technology to be used for ticketing. Learn more about SoundVue noise cameras that are used by New York City by watching this quick video.

Update: August 2025: Pilot program approved by City Council.

Did you catch this story on CityNEWS? It is August in Edmonton and that means we experience Folk Fest, Fringe, and excessively noisy vehicles. I have been highlighting this issue for years, and we have made progress on holding these drivers accountable with increased fine amounts and greater attention from the police.

But with gaps in enforcement abilities, the issue has persisted. Cities around the world are moving forward with automated noise technology to crack down on street racing, dangerous driving, and excessive vehicle noise. The Wall Street Journal this week heralded them as the “new frontier in automated traffic enforcement". From use in the UK to New York City and other cities in the United States, noise cameras are becoming more prevalent.

Unlike the 2019 machines (which functioned more as a display board informing the driver of their noise), the new technology has rapidly advanced in precision and utility. It has been challenged and successfully held up in court. There is a small machine that targets vehicle noise and identifies the offending vehicles, snapping pictures of the license plates. It can provide the plates as well as data such as the number of violations, the times, and the decibel readings.

Please watch this quick video to see how the SoundVue Cameras work: (https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=fugG21A4RnU7IsZS&t=1041&v=hqNELalqoCc&feature=youtu.be)

While there are provincial guidelines for automated enforcement, especially related to ticketing, I believe there is much more that we can and must do to support the Edmonton Police Service in upholding traffic safety and holding irresponsible, law-breaking drivers accountable.

Even if these machines cannot be used to administer tickets, they are still incredibly valuable for a number of reasons.

First, for the purpose of research and advocacy and to support the Edmonton Police Service in their enforcement operations. The police can’t be everywhere all the time, and we need to do what we can to maximize the use of their resources and ensure a strategic deployment is made. This would inform future project TENSOR deployments.

Second, the video and plates of offending vehicles would be provided to the EPS team. Currently if you report a vehicle or plate using the form provided by EPS, an officer will call the offending vehicle and ask them to seek out repair or give them a warning for the file. If you have a picture of the vehicle, they may ask you to go to a station and swear a statement. I have been told by law enforcement officials that the more information you can provide, the better. Right now, enforcement is heavily dependent on complaints from residents, and many of you have shared with me that this process is onerous and difficult (can you spot a make or model or plate of a vehicle at high speed?). Ultimately, my goal is not fine revenue, my goal is safety and behavior change. Even warnings on file are helpful for future law enforcement interactions.

Third, these machines would provide conclusive, concrete data to help highlight the severity and nature of the issue. Despite this being a frequent source of complaint by many residents, the issue has been minimized in the past or dismissed. While city council voted unanimously to raise the fines, the missing link remains enforcement. This new technology would be able to say X violations occurred at Y decibels and help us further make the case to the Minister and others. 

Fourth, if the technology is a good fit, and the Minister increases safety and enforcement opportunities under automated enforcement, these machines would be ready to provide enforcement assistance immediately.

There is a huge opportunity here for Alberta to demonstrate creative solutions that cut red tape while ensuring safety on our roadways. With the number of tragic fatalities on our roads, we need every tool at our disposal to mitigate noise, but also dangerous driving and street racing.

BACKGROUND AND FOR REFERENCE 

New York City Annual Noise Report

https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dep/downloads/pdf/air/noise/annual-report-noise-camera-enforcement-program.pdf

Noise emissions from loud vehicle engines or mufflers can impinge on the quality of life in New York City. Some vehicle noise is so loud that it can even be a source of harmful public health impacts, such as sleep deprivation and hearing loss. In recent years, complaints about loud vehicle engines and mufflers have increased. The Department of Environmental Protection’s Noise Camera Enforcement Program was created to combat this excessive noise. With strategically placed noise cameras, the Department (“DEP”) identifies vehicles that exceed the New York City Noise Code’s limits. A summons can be issued to any vehicle found to be violating these limits using evidence gathered by the camera.

EPS Vehicle Noise Complaint Form:

https://www.edmontonpolice.ca/TrafficVehicles/TrafficConcerns/VehicleNoise

All Traffic Concerns received are placed in a queue awaiting intake and review for enforcement and/or monitoring considerations. Should your Traffic Concern be assigned to a member of the Traffic Section, you may be contacted to obtain additional information and/or to inform you of the enforcement action taken.

If contact information is not provided and pertinent details are missing, there is no guarantee that any further action will be taken to address the concerns outlined.

 

 

Update: May 2025: Speakers needed at Edmonton Police Commission:
This is not only deafening, but very dangerous. Multiple fatalities have already occurred already this year. You can register to speak to the police oversight body, the Edmonton Police Commission (virtual or in person) Thursday May 15th and ask them about their traffic safety plan.
Update: July, 2024:
The Edmonton Police have asked your support in noise reporting form here:
Please help them identify hotspots and provide data to dispatch resources.

UPDATE: Feb 24th, 2023
Increased fine bylaw passed unanimously increasing noise bylaw to $1000.
City Council passed UNANIMOUSLY a new noise bylaw that increased ticketing to $1000 (and doubling per offence) for violations. Please read more at edmonton.ca and continue to show your support through measures below.
Increased Fines will hopefully serve as a deterrent, however effective enforcement through automated cameras such as those used in New York, London, Paris and other cities is the most promising tool for consistent and equitable enforcement. Please keep advocating to the provincial government for regulatory changes to empower noise enforcement.
New section in Bylaw to address excessive vehicle noise 
February 24, 2023
Today, City Council amended Traffic Bylaw 5590 to create a new offence for excessive vehicle noise. Previously, only excessive motorcycle noise was included. 
Currently, City of Edmonton Peace Officers, in collaboration with the Edmonton Police Service, enforce excessive passenger vehicle noise offences using the provincial Traffic Safety Act and its Regulations, and excessive motorcycle noise through the Community Standards Bylaw.
The new offence and fine amount is intended to work as an additional deterrent to excessive vehicle noise when offences in Alberta’s Traffic Safety Act have been exhausted and are not serving as a meaningful deterrent and in cases where the seriousness of the offence merits its use. Enforcement officers will exercise discretion when applying this new offence recognizing each situation can be unique and doesn’t always warrant a ticket.
Under this new section, excessive vehicle noise carries a fine of $1,000 and is doubled for a subsequent offence.
The new offence comes into effect today. 

Take Action: UCP Transportation Minister Dreeshan said photo radar can’t be used for noise violations

CALL TO ACTION:

Please Call Minister Devin Dreeshen (780-427-2080) and ask for his help to silence the noisy vehicles.

We know that this technology can have the needed precision to hand out tickets on noisy vehicles and already is working in London, Paris, New York, and others. But this technology is being blocked by the Alberta UCP from use in Alberta because it's been included in their photo radar moratorium.

You can call his office and leave a message with his staff who will let him know. I'm told by people at the Legislature that phone calls weigh  heavily  on the Ministers.

DEVIN DREESHEN, Honourable - Minister of Transportation - Office of the Minister
Phone: 780 427-2080

Too late to phone? Send an email!  (Please BCC my office at [email protected])

Here's a draft that I encourage you to customize:

E-mail: [email protected],

Subject: Please help address stunting, Dangerous driving, and excessive noise 

Minister Dreeshen,

I am a resident of Edmonton and I urge you to take any and all action in your legislative authority to empower municipalities and law enforcement to address the issues of noisy vehicles, stunting, and dangerous driving behaviour.

The excessive noise is only part of the harm these drivers are choosing to inflict on our community with these optional modifications.

The Edmonton Police acknowledge this is a serious issue: https://www.edmontonpolice.ca/TrafficVehicles/TrafficNoise

Noisy vehicles are often modified to be excessively noisy and are frustrating the police, neighbours, businesses and families. We need your help addressing this nuissance and public safety concern. 

This could be a big win for us all with no downside to you, as you just need to pass the laws which the local municipalities will enforce, fund, resource, and action.

Sincerely,

Name

Address

PS: Given the public health implications cited, I would encourage you to talk with the Health Minister: 

https://edmonton.taproot.news/news/2022/08/08/more-than-an-annoyance-traffic-noise-is-a-matter-of-public-health


SECOND REQUEST:
Please share your views with other members of Edmonton City Council: [email protected] 

TAKE ACTION:

Please email: [email protected] and please cc Police Commission Chair John McDougall and, if you wish, City Council: [email protected]


Draft message - Please Copy / Paste / Customize

To: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

Subject: Dangerous Vehicle Behaviour and Noise Violations

 

Dear Municipal Leaders,

I am writing to urge you to take action on the enforcement of noisy vehicles. Excessive noise, dangerous driving, and stunting pose a major safety issue in the community to neighbours and our pets.

I live in <neighbourhood> and am negatively impacted by noise on a regular basis. 

Modified vehicles are already illegal. Please enforce the law.

These modified exhausts serve no purpose but to create noise. They use bridges, underpasses and lower than grade roadways as echo chambers, rev up engines while in neutral/clutch disengaged. They disturb our homes, our sleep, and our patio experiences. For what?

These vehicles should be removed from the roadways under the TSA which will act as a severe deterrent to all like-minded drivers:

The deafening popping noise you hear is caused by this modification https://www.motorhills.com/how-to-make-any-car-backfire-7-ways/#:~:text=The%20way%20to%20make%20your,that%20muffle%20the%20exhaust%20sound which, ironically, decreases performance. It also burns excess fuel contributing to climate change.

 

Division 2
Vehicles, Equipment, Accidents
and Removal of Vehicles

Equipment standards

65(1)  Except as otherwise permitted under this Act, a person shall not do any of the following:

(a) drive or operate a vehicle on a highway unless that vehicle complies with the vehicle and equipment standards set out in the regulations in respect of that vehicle;

Inspection of vehicles

66(1)  A peace officer may, for the purposes of

(f) direct that the vehicle or its equipment, or both, be removed from the highway or from operation and that it not be returned to a highway or operation until the vehicle or its equipment, or both, have been, as the case may be,

(4)  If a driver or an owner of a vehicle is given a direction under subsection (1)(f), a peace officer may seize the licence plate and certificate of registration issued in respect of that vehicle, and in the case of a vehicle in a prescribed class of commercial vehicles, a peace officer may seize the certificate of registration or a copy of the certificate of registration, and hold the licence plate and certificate of registration or copy of the certificate of registration, as the case may be, until the vehicle or its equipment, or both, have been, in accordance with the direction,

VEHICLE EQUIPMENT REGULATION AR 122/2009

Mufflers 

61(1)  A motor vehicle propelled by an internal combustion engine must have an exhaust muffler that cools and expels the exhaust gases from the engine without excessive noise and without producing flames or sparks.

(2)  A person shall not drive or operate a motor vehicle propelled by an internal combustion engine if the exhaust outlet of the muffler has been widened.

(3)  A person shall not drive or operate a motor vehicle propelled by an internal combustion engine if a device is attached to the exhaust system or the muffler that increases the noise made by the expulsion of gases from the engine or allows a flame to be ignited from the exhaust system. 

(4)  This section applies to a power bicycle that is propelled by an internal combustion engine. 

 

Sincerely,

<Resident>


Legacy work on this file: maintained for posterity
UPDATE: August 12th, 2022:
I will provide the following Motion for debate:

Motion: 

  1. That Administration prepare bylaw amendments to:

    1. create an excessive noise offence applicable to passenger vehicles with a fine amount of $5,000 for a first offence and $10,000 for a second offence; and

    2.  increase the fine amount for the motorcycle noise offence to $5,000 for a first offence and $10,000 for a second offence,
      and return to Committee.

Due Date: November 21, 2022, Community and Public Services Committee 


  1. That Community and Public Services Committee recommend to City Council:

    1. That the Mayor on behalf of City Council advocate to the Government of Alberta to recognize automated roadway noise enforcement tools and allows municipalities to use them for noise infractions.

    2. That the Mayor on behalf of City Council advocate to the Government of Alberta for the Traffic Safety Act to be amended to allow municipalities to ban vehicle modifications that cause for excessive roadway noise and explore tools to restrict the sale of said products.

    3. That the Mayor on behalf of City Council advocate to the Government of Alberta for the Traffic Safety Act to be amended to allow municipalities to seize vehicles driving in excess of 50 KM/H over the speed limit.

No vehicle is sold noisy. Vehicles have mufflers and must be illegally modified, often with illegal aftermarket products to be excessively noisy.

Council has the opportunity to request a report from the administration to support a dramatic increase in action where half-measures have previously failed. Project TENSOR and previous noise reduction efforts have been insufficient because of the deafening noise along many streets last summer. Cracking down on noisy vehicles will support the council in traffic safety as there is a strong correlation between excessive noise and speed.

We don't need driver education; we need enforcement. We don't need warnings; we need tickets and impounding.
The maximum allowable fine could be increased up to $10,000. The current 85-decibel limit may be too high and require a reduction to 74 decibels like in Europe. Community members also suggested noise curfews forbidding noisy motorcycles after certain hours or outright motorcycle bans along certain roads (Whyte Avenue, Saskatchewan Drive, Groat Road, Connors Road, for instance).
It's time for a crackdown.
Across Canada, citizens are demanding real traffic enforcement against excessive vehicle noise is the result of speeding, aggressive and dangerous driving, and modified exhaust systems — commonly associated with street racing and stunt driving frequently at night. (Toronto: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/excessive-vehicle-noise-residents-call-for-action-city-1.6508817)
What vehicle modifications are already illegal in Alberta? (Traffic Safety Act and Edmonton Noise Bylaws)

Exhaust regulations

  • A motor vehicle propelled by an internal combustion engine must have an exhaust muffler that cools and expels the exhaust gases from the engine without excessive noise and without producing flames or sparks.
  • A person shall not drive or operate a motor vehicle propelled by an internal combustion engine if the exhaust outlet of the muffler has been widened.
  • A person shall not drive or operate a motor vehicle propelled by an internal combustion engine if a device is attached to the exhaust system or the muffler that increases the noise made by the expulsion of gases from the engine.

Beyond the regulations above, a vehicle with a modified exhaust may also produce noise in violation of municipal bylaws.

If you are in breach of any of the equipment violations, the following could happen:
  1. You will be issued a summons for the infraction.
  2. You will be issued a vehicle compliance form. This means:
    • You will be given 60 days to repair the problem and be instructed to attend a district office to show that the repair has been completed.
    • The vehicle may be directed to a repair facility of your choice to have the repairs done.
    • The vehicle cannot be driven until the repairs are completed.
    • The officer may seize the license plate and not return it until the repairs are completed.

It is not illegal to sell modifications; it is up to the consumer to be aware of what modifications they want to do and educate themselves with the laws and also to speak to law enforcement for advice if they are unsure of what is acceptable.

If you purchase a vehicle and it has modifications it is your responsibility to make sure that the vehicle conforms to the vehicle equipment regulation. If the modifications are in contravention of the regulation, arrangements should be made to correct this or you will be subject to the fines associated with the infraction.

News coverage:

CBC News: Drivers behind Noisy Vehicles Deserve Stiffer Fines

Will you sign?

I support Edmonton City Council taking measures to silence the noisy vehicles, dangerous driving and would like to receive updates how to help.

Saving…

Take action

AMA with Denis Agar, Executive Director of MOVEMENT, the Metro Vancouver Transit Riders Non-Profit
Send a Custom Letter: Fund Public Transit
Email: